MCA Broker vs Direct Funder
Merchant cash advance broker vs direct funder: what changes for you.
A direct funder is the company that buys your future sales with its own money and signs the merchant cash advance contract, while a broker, like Afterfirst, funds nothing and sends your file to several funders so you can compare their offers. Either way, you repay the funder, not the broker, so compare the offers themselves and ask the broker how it's paid.
What should you know first about brokers and direct funders?
The short version: the funder sets the price and holds the contract, the broker shops your file, and the written disclosure tells you who gets paid what.
- Who funds: only the funder. A broker never holds your money and isn't a party to the payback terms.
- Who you repay: the funder, or a company it names to collect for it. That doesn't change if a broker found the deal.
- Who pays the broker: usually the funder, out of the deal. In Texas and Virginia, the funder's disclosure has to say whether it pays a broker and how much.
- Up-front fees: in Florida and Kansas, a broker can't charge you an advance fee for its services.
- Registration: Connecticut, Virginia, Texas and Missouri require brokers to register with a state office, and Missouri also requires a bond.
- After funding: the holder named in your contract, or its servicer, takes the debits, answers reconciliation requests and approves any change.
How do a broker and a direct funder compare?
| Direct funder | Broker | |
|---|---|---|
| Whose money | Its own | The funder's; the broker never holds the funds |
| How many offers | One, or a no | As many as the funders that fit send back |
| Who you pay back | The funder | The funder, the same as going direct |
| Who pays the broker | No broker | Usually the funder, from the deal |
| Where the broker's pay shows | Nowhere | In states like Connecticut and Virginia, on the disclosure form |
| If you're declined | You start over somewhere else | The broker can try funders with different criteria |
| Harder files | Depends on that one funder's rules | A broker can look for funders that take second positions or consolidations |
After funding, nothing about the broker touches your payments. The funder collects, and the funder answers reconciliation requests.
Does a broker make the advance cost more?
It can. The broker's commission comes out of the deal, and funders price deals to cover what it costs them to find customers. A direct funder has its own costs to find you too: ads, sales staff, lead lists. So the honest answer is that the only way to know is to compare the actual offers.
Some states now make that easier. Connecticut's disclosure form has a box for broker compensation paid from the financed amount. Virginia's required disclosures include broker compensation too. If your state has a form, read that line.
What does the difference look like in dollars?
Example only. These are made-up figures to show the math, not a quote or a typical offer.
Say you need $40,000. A direct funder offers 1.42. A broker comes back with two offers. Here's how to line them up:
| Direct offer | Broker offer 1 | Broker offer 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advance | $40,000 | $40,000 | $40,000 |
| Factor rate | 1.42 | 1.36 | 1.45 |
| Fees taken out | $800 | $1,200 | $0 |
| Cash that reaches you | $39,200 | $38,800 | $40,000 |
| Total payback | $56,800 | $54,400 | $58,000 |
| Cost per $1 you receive | $0.45 | $0.40 | $0.45 |
Broker offer 1 is cheapest per dollar even with the higher fee. Broker offer 2 has no fee but costs the same per dollar as going direct. Put your own offers into the offer comparison tool to see the same lines, including an estimated APR.
Who holds and services your contract after funding?
The company named as the purchaser in your agreement holds the contract, and it or a servicer it appoints runs the account until it's paid. The broker's part usually ends when the deal funds.
What does the holder do?
The holder owns the share of future sales it bought. It sets the daily or weekly debit, decides on reconciliation requests, issues payoff letters and approves any settlement. It may also have filed a UCC financing statement against your business.
What does a servicer do?
Some funders hire another company to collect payments, post them and answer account questions. A servicer acts for the holder, so its name can show up on your bank debits even though it never funded you.
Can the contract be sold or shared?
Yes. A funder can sell the contract to another company or bring in partners who each own a slice of it. The company that funded you may then service it for the new owners, or hand it off. Your assignment clause says whether this can happen without asking you.
Where does the broker fit after funding?
A broker can help you gather records and draft a request, but it can't change your payment, waive a fee or release a lien. Send anything that matters to the holder or servicer in the way the contract requires.
How do you find the holder in your agreement and on your bank statement?
Start with the signed agreement, because it names the purchaser and where notices go. Then match that name to the debits on your bank statement.
Where should you look in the agreement?
- The first page and the signature block: the purchaser or funder named on those pages is the original holder.
- The notice section: the address or email where reconciliation and payoff requests must go.
- The assignment clause: whether the holder can sell the contract or name a servicer.
- The ACH authorization: the company allowed to debit your account, which may be a servicer.
- The disclosure form, if your state requires one: the provider's name and, in some states, the broker's pay.
What does the debit on your bank statement show?
Each ACH debit carries a short company name and often an ID. Compare it with the names in your contract. A short or coded name is common, so ask your bank for the full originator details on one debit if you can't match it.
What if the names don't match?
Ask the company debiting you, in writing, to confirm who holds the contract and who services it. Keep the reply with your contract. If no one can show you authority to collect, raise it with your bank and a business attorney.
What do state broker-disclosure laws require?
A growing number of states set rules for brokers of sales-based financing, mainly registration, a ban on up-front fees and disclosure of broker pay. These are the rules we've checked against each state's own site:
| State | What it requires of brokers | Official source |
|---|---|---|
| Connecticut | Brokers and providers register with the Department of Banking, and the disclosure form shows broker compensation paid from the financed amount. | CT Department of Banking |
| Virginia | Brokers register with the State Corporation Commission, and the provider states whether it pays a broker and how much. | Va. Code 6.2-2228 et seq. |
| Texas | Brokers register with the Office of Consumer Credit Commissioner, the disclosure states any broker pay, and each violation carries a $10,000 civil penalty. | Tex. Fin. Code ch. 398 |
| Florida | A broker can't charge you an advance fee for its services or make false statements to get you to sign. | Fla. Stat. 559.9614 |
| Kansas | A broker can't assess, collect or solicit an advance fee from your business. | Kansas SB 345 |
| Missouri | A broker registers with the Division of Finance and keeps a bond on file before doing business. | RSMo 427.300 |
Texas also makes a confession of judgment clause in these contracts void, under the same chapter.
Check whether your own state has broker rules too. Ask the broker which state rules it follows for your deal, and get its answer in writing.
What happens when your deposits stop?
Your obligations run to the holder, not the broker, so the broker can't pause your debits when sales fall. The contract decides what happens next.
If sales drop, find the reconciliation section and the notice section in your agreement. Ask the holder or servicer how to request a reconciliation, send it in the form the notice section asks for, and keep proof you sent it. Before you change any debit or bank account, read what the contract and the personal guarantee you signed say about it, and put your questions to the holder in writing.
Before you take a new advance to cover an old one, ask how it will affect your daily cash. Both sets of debits will come out of the same deposits.
Does it matter whether a broker or a funder arranged the deal?
Not for the payback. Your contract terms, your debit and your rights are the same whether you found the funder on your own or a broker brought the offer. What a broker can change is the number of offers you see before you sign, and that choice is worth the most before funding, not after.
Keep a simple file for each advance: the signed contract, the disclosure, the payoff letter, the name on the debit and every request you've sent. If a problem comes up, that file shows who holds the contract and what you asked for, and when.
What are the red flags in a broker or funder pitch?
The biggest red flag is any fee you pay before an offer funds. Watch for these too:
- The company says it's a direct funder, but a different name appears on the contract.
- It won't tell you how it's paid, or the disclosure doesn't match what it said.
- It pushes you to sign before you've read the payback, the fees and the debit amount.
- It tells you to stop paying a current funder before a new deal is in place.
- It can't say whether it's registered in a state that requires it.
Federal agencies act on these practices too. In the FTC's case against RCG Advances, a court entered a $20.3 million judgment against an MCA operator for deceiving small businesses.
What do owners ask most about brokers and direct funders?
Can a broker change my payment after funding?
No. Only the holder of the contract, or a servicer it has authorized in writing, can approve a lower payment, a reconciliation or a payoff. A broker can help you ask, but the decision isn't the broker's.
Does going direct always cost less?
Not always. A direct funder has its own costs to find customers, and a broker can return a cheaper offer from another funder. Compare the cash that reaches you and the total payback on each written offer.
How do I know if a company is a broker or a funder?
Ask whose money funds the deal, then check the contract. The funder is the party named as the purchaser of your future receivables. If the company you spoke with isn't named there, it acted as a broker.
Who do I call if my debits look wrong?
Call the servicer named in your contract's notice section, and send the same request in writing to the address the contract lists. Check the notice section to see whether a phone call counts as notice.
Does a broker have to tell me what it earns?
In some states the funder's disclosure has to show broker pay. Texas and Virginia require a statement of whether the funder pays a broker and how much, and Connecticut's form has a broker compensation line.
What should you ask before you choose?
What should you ask a broker?
- Do you charge me anything up front? In Florida and Kansas, a broker can't collect an advance fee from you.
- How are you paid, and how much is it in dollars on my deal?
- Will you talk with me before you send my file anywhere, and which funders will see it?
- Are you registered where my state requires it? Connecticut, Virginia and Texas register brokers, and Missouri requires broker registration with a bond.
- Will every offer come back to me, or only the one you pick?
What should you ask a direct funder?
- Is this your money, or are you placing the deal with someone else?
- What's the payback, the fees, and the cash that reaches my account?
- Is there an early payoff discount, in writing?
- How does reconciliation work if my sales drop?
When does each one fit?
Go direct when you already have an offer you like from a funder you trust, your file is simple, and you don't need to compare. Use a broker when you want more than one offer, when a funder has already said no, or when you carry an open advance and need a second position or a consolidation.
Here's how we work: we read your file, talk with you before we shop it, send it only to funders that fit, and bring back every offer. Applying costs you nothing, and Afterfirst MCA charges you no fee. Funding companies pay us a monthly membership and a commission when a deal funds.
Where do these facts come from?
- Federal Trade Commission, FTC v. RCG Advances, LLC (S.D.N.Y.)
- Connecticut Department of Banking, commercial financing guidance and disclosure form
- Code of Virginia, title 6.2, chapter 22.1 (sales-based financing)
- Texas Finance Code, chapter 398 (commercial sales-based financing)
- Florida Senate, Fla. Stat. 559.9614 (prohibited acts by brokers)
- Kansas Secretary of State, SB 345, Commercial Financing Disclosure Act
- Missouri Revisor of Statutes, RSMo 427.300 (commercial financing disclosure)
Behind on an advance, or about to be?
We can check whether consolidation or a reverse consolidation fits before anything gets worse. Call 877-FUND-654 with any question. We call you back, and we always talk with you before we shop your file.